Zoom Logo

Public Banking: Sustaining Economic Equity for the Bay Area - Shared screen with speaker view
Debbie Notkin
27:51
publicbankeastbay.org
Susan Harman, Public Bank East Bay, she/her
28:03
PublicBankEastBay.org
Debbie Notkin/Friends of the Public Bank East Bay
34:13
https://revealnews.org/podcast/the-red-line-racial-disparities-in-lending-2/
Des Buford | Justice Funders | (she/her/Des)
36:39
Gracias Val for that wonderful speed primer on Public Banks! Greatly appreciated!
Debbie Notkin/Friends of the Public Bank East Bay
47:36
Thank you, David, especially for making time during those crucial closing arguments!
MicheleRutherford First5Alameda (she/her)
47:42
Thank you, David, for your leadership in this and all things for our communities and families.
David Chiu
48:33
Sorry I need to run, but if anyone has followup questions, my policy director Rebekah Krell is on this call, and we can get answers after this session. Appreciate everyone's engagement on this!
Erin Ceynar, Tides Foundation (she/her)
59:24
So wonderful to see you on this call, Eric! I'm a North Dakotan - Watford City and Fort Berthold. My grandparents were NPLers. My student loan - University of ND - was thro the Bank of ND. Grateful for this community asset! Has helped my agrarian family for five generations.
Brandi B
59:50
Thanks so much for sharing!
Didacus Ramos
01:03:19
Also, PublicBankEastBay.org
Julie Boudreau
01:07:16
I see this as a cause that might spark conservative-progressive alliances. Is that naive, or have you all seen some of that?
Val Red-Horse Mohl, EBCF (she/her)
01:07:56
I agree Julie!
Didacus Ramos
01:09:06
The purpose of the Public Bank is to close the loop so that more public funds stay in the community. In that regard, Public Banks are apolitical.
Debbie Notkin/Friends of the Public Bank East Bay
01:10:19
@JulieBoudreau, absolutely. We just need to get over some of the knee-jerk polarization that arises.
Susan Harman, Public Bank East Bay, she/her
01:10:38
During lobbying for AB 857 we tried hard to appeal to conservatives, and couldn’t get any traction. We see many ways that public banks can ally with conservatives, and we continue to reach out to them. We can also use any suggestions you have!
Kurtis Wu
01:11:47
I always joke that the only Public Bank in the country is in the great progressive state of North Dakota
Hank Levy, Alameda County (he/his/him)
01:14:39
I have heard that public banking was attempted in other states, around the same time that the BND started, but that they did not stay in existence. I am unaware of any studies about this movement, and why the BND succeeded and other state banks failed.
George Syrop, PBEB (he/him)
01:18:23
https://www.publicbankeastbay.org
George Syrop, PBEB (he/him)
01:19:12
publicbankeastbay@gmail.com
Julie Boudreau
01:21:04
The knee-jerk polarization is discouraging. I’m from the agricultural CA Central Valley and wonder what it might be like to reach out to independent farmers.
Debbie Notkin/Friends of the Public Bank East Bay
01:24:00
Independent farmers, especially farmers of color, are a group we would love to connect with (primarily in the East Bay for our initiative, but throughout California for the movement). Julie, we welcome suggestions and approaches: publicbankeastbay@gmail.com
Julie Boudreau
01:24:26
Thanks!
Erin Ceynar, Tides Foundation (she/her)
01:24:45
Kurtis, as a North Dakotan living in the Bay Area I get the sarcasm. It is a very red state but is fiercely local. Here's a recent story demonstrating this. Sarah Vogel is a hero in the state. I encourage everyone to read her book - The Farmer's Daughter - The ND Nine and the Fight to Save the Family Farm. https://www.agweek.com/news/policy/sarah-vogel-says-north-dakota-attorney-general-didnt-see-documents-on-bill-gates-land-deal
Julie Boudreau
01:25:12
I unfortunately have to jump off for another meeting but look forward to watching the recording later. Great presentation!
Don Falk
01:28:31
Thank you for organizing this session; I have learned so much.I am curious and maybe confused about one element, regarding how public banks might interact or compete with CDFIs. If public banks are lending for affordable housing, does that not potentially take business away from those nonprofit lenders? Or would public banks be making loans that CDFIs don't have the financial capacity or willingness to make, e.g., by taking more risk or being a stronger equitable lens to lending?
Brian McKeown
01:29:01
Thank you Fred for supporting the beginning of Kiva Oakland for economic racial equity justice as well, you were instrumental on that front too!
Debbie Notkin/Friends of the Public Bank East Bay
01:29:20
I can answer that in the chat, or George S. should be able to answer as a speaker.
Fred Blackwell | SF Foundation | he,him
01:30:05
Don think about public bank as wholesale v CDFI as retail
Susan Harman, Public Bank East Bay, she/her
01:31:49
Yes, Fred, we say public banks are wholesale, or function toward local financial institutions the way the Federal Reserve does.
Kurtis Wu
01:33:51
Thank you!
Margie Lewis she/her
01:34:28
The Governance will help with this.
MicheleRutherford First5Alameda (she/her)
01:35:45
In SF we built child care centers using community development loans that we subsidized with GF, structured to meet certain requirements. Could you speak a little more about loan products or strategies to finance projects that typically don't "pencil out"? Also, has their been discussion regarding child care as a small business?
Sarah Frankfurth | NCG | she/her
01:37:15
https://publicbankeastbay.org/boardapplicants
Margie Lewis she/her
01:37:44
We have spoken with coops and Land Trusts and would build produvts that would address their needs.
Brian McKeown
01:40:00
loan guarantees, collateralization and interest rate subsidization are a couple of avenues to reduce costs, and increase the viability of projects
Didacus Ramos
01:41:07
+1 Brian McKeowan. This is not a small point or minor issue.
Margie Lewis she/her
01:41:09
We also plan to create an Academy to help with Financial literacy foor the community and our community Bank Board members and th Board memb ers who are not familiar with working with Community.
MicheleRutherford First5Alameda (she/her)
01:41:27
Thank you Debbie and Val.
George Syrop, PBEB (he/him)
01:46:41
https://www.publicbankeastbay.org
Leo Zambrano (he/him)
01:46:49
I agree with you Val on reaching across the aisle--the agrarian roots of ND's public bank gives hope that we can head in the same direction
Val Red-Horse Mohl, EBCF (she/her)
01:47:08
Love that!
Andrew Hattori (he/him)
01:48:09
Thank you everyone for today's terrific conversation and insight into what Public Bank East Bay means for our community!
George Syrop, PBEB (he/him)
01:48:12
One particular talking point that we've found appeals to folks on both sides of the aisle is that a public bank helps increase public revenue WITHOUT increasing taxes
George Syrop, PBEB (he/him)
01:48:15
Thank you everyone!
May Leong - EBCF
01:48:21
Thanks Everyone!!
Brandi B
01:48:23
Great presentation!
Des Buford | Justice Funders | (she/her/Des)
01:48:23
Thank you all!